Assignment
Description
Educators often
turn to research-based articles in journals and newsletters and
on professional association websites to help them make professional
decisions. This assignment gives you an opportunity to explore a
literacy instruction question that is important to your professional
role. Instead of a traditional review of research paper, you will
participate in a Writing Workshop to prepare an article for a professional
journal, newsletter or website that is solidly grounded in research
and that has potential to inform your own and others’ professional
practice.
Just
like a review of research paper, an effective research-based article
addresses a key literacy issue or question, reviews relevant literacy
research that has been done to answer that question, and makes
concrete instructional or curricular recommendations. However,
the voice and tone of the article are more flexible, the writing
geared for practitioners, and the recommendations immediately
useful in K-12 schools. Our Writing Workshops will guide you to
prepare an article that is engagingly written, thoroughly grounded
in effective literacy research, and provides useable information
for educators.
Process
and Writing Workshop Assignments:
1. Clarify research interest(s):
Consider your particular professional role and setting -- either
your current educational role or your future professional role
as a literacy specialist, general education or special education
teacher, school psychologist, or counselor. What burning questions
come up for you about literacy and how you can positively impact
the literacy lives of K-12 students? NOTE: Because this course
addresses general literacy development and research based best
practices in instruction, please target your research interests
accordingly.
June 25: Come to class ready to share possible research topics.
2. Examine models of articles:
Explore journals, newsletters, and websites that publish articles
on the topic(s) you have selected. We will spend some time on
this in class on June 18. The process of looking at sample articles
will help you develop a focus for your article.
June 25: Bring at least one research article from a professional
journal, newsletter, or web site that you feel meets our criteria
above (e.g., engaging, grounded in research according to criteria
in Allington, p. 24-25, useful information for educators).
3. Develop a research question:
A research-based article typically answers a question related
to a specific literacy issue (e.g., what is the impact of family
literacy on student achievement? What instructional practices
increase the effectiveness of graphic organizers? How can discussion
help students construct a deeper understanding of what they read?
What are the research-based strengths and weaknesses of early
intervention programs in literacy? What characteristics of grouping
for instruction have been shown to improve students’ reading
achievement?). The challenge will be finding a question that is
focused enough to be handled effectively in an article (as opposed
to broad enough for a dissertation).
Your article must consider issues of diversity, the relationship
between research and instructional practice, and ethics related
to your topic. As you develop your research question, keep these
considerations in mind.
July 2: Form your research interest into one (or several) research
questions that you will share in class.
4. Identify a publication target:
Select a journal, professional newsletter, or website where you
would want to publish an article on your selected research question.
Familiarize yourself with the appropriate guidelines for contributors
or authors. Read sample articles to get a sense of the scope,
voice, and format published in this venue. This research will
give you valuable insights into how you need to structure and
write your article.
July 9: Bring to class with a sample article that exemplifies
the characteristics of articles in your target publication.
5. Gather research:
Read a broad selection of research studies pertaining to your
topic (5 - 10 articles). This reading phase should help you sharpen
your question and give you a good idea of the depth and kind of
information available. After reading, choose the best, most relevant
studies you have found. In your review, you must include at least
three articles that are reports of research studies. The research
studies you cite must meet Allington’s definition of scientifically-based
reading research (Allington, 2006, p. 24-25). You may supplement
with others that are reviews of research or application articles
pertaining to the topic. Take notes on the articles using the
Research Review Notes handout.
July 9: Bring the three most cogent research articles and your
Research Review Notes to discuss in class.
6. Draft the article:
Your article will briefly review relevant research on your topic,
follow APA guidelines, and be a maximum of 10 pages (double spaced,
12-point font). NOTE: 10 pages
is the outside target length; you may be able to write a highly
effective article that is less than 10 pages. However, your article
can be no longer than 10 pages. During the
Writing Workshop on July 9, we’ll explore how to structure
the article, how to begin with an engaging lead, and how to work
with APA conventions (e.g., citations, references). We will also
work with graphic organizers as a tool for planning the entire
article.
July 16: Bring to class a graphic organizer showing the overall
structure of your article with the key ideas/components listed.
In addition, bring a draft of any part of the article so that
you can work on revision strategies during the workshop. The draft
does not need to be long (aim for 1-2 pages).
Although the specific structure of your article will vary from
publication to publication, you need to include the following
components (review the assignment rubric for specific criteria
that will be evaluated):
A. Clear introduction
that explains the literacy research question and its relevance.
Describe your question in "real world" terms and explain
why it is important in your particular professional setting. The
Introduction briefly summarizes why you have undertaken the review.
In this section, discuss how your topic reflects issues of diversity,
instructional practice, and ethics. Include an engaging “hook”
to entice the reader into the article. More
information here
B. Review of research.
This is the main section of your article, your opportunity to
"make your case" based on the evidence of others' research
and practice. Include at least three articles that report research
studies that contribute information about your question. Synthesize
the information you gathered from the different research studies
by drawing connections among them – what, as a whole, do
these studies taken together contribute to our understanding of
your question? Your goal is to weave the research articles together
into a cohesive statement of support for your article. More
information here
C. Discussion of the research and
implications for professional practice. Based
on the findings of the research studies and other articles you
have cited, explain how the research has answered your original
question or solved your original problem. Discuss the instructional
implications of the research. Explain how the research has provided
guidance for real-world educators and learners. Tie in what you
have learned about diversity, instructional practice, and ethics
related to your topic. More
information here
D. Conclusion. The
conclusion should tie directly back to the reasons for pursuing
the topic that you raised in the introductory section. In a few
sentences, synthesize what we now know about the question you
posed. More
information here
E. References. List
the references cited in your paper in correct APA format. Include
every reference cited within the body of the paper and only those
references actually cited. More
information and resources for APA format here
F. Reflection. Briefly
reflect (2 pgs maximum; the reflection is not part of the article
page count) on your experience researching this topic and writing
the article. In your reflection, answer the following questions:
What specific implications of this research do you see for your
own professional practice? In what ways has this article strengthened
your knowledge and skills as a professional? How will you use
what you have learned to improve your service to colleagues, students,
families, and the wider community?
7. Revise and polish your article. We will spend time during the
Writing Workshops on July 16, 23, and 30 exploring revision, peer
response, and polishing strategies.
July 23 and 30: Bring drafts of your article to class to work
with during the Writing Workshops. Final Article Due: August 6
RESEARCH
SYMPOSIUM PRESENTATION
On August 6 we will hold our Literacy Research and Practice Symposium.
That’s a fancy name for a very informal, engaging, and enlightening
event. During the Symposium, four or five of you will present
simultaneously with the rest of the class rotating among the “sessions.”
This works much like a poster session at a professional conference
with different presenters speaking simultaneously -- yet all in
the same room. Plan to discuss your article very briefly and informally
as your classmates circulate among the projects. Because of the
format, please plan to discuss your article informally for a couple
of minutes, rather than preparing a formal presentation. Prepare
a one-page handout to give to your classmates. This handout should
describe the application implications from your article in enough
detail for your colleagues to think about it in terms of their
own professional roles and should include applicable bibliographic
references from your article. Please make sure that your name
is on your handout. Bring enough copies of the handout for everyone.
The presentation must use some kind of visual aid to illustrate
major concepts (e.g., graph, photographs, samples of student work,
examples of materials related to your topic). This does not need
to be elaborate – just provide us with visuals that will
help us understand your topic and the research you reviewed. You
must present in class to receive credit.